Weekly Carlisle Real Estate Sold Comparables Report | October 5 through 11, 2026

So that you can make an up-to-date and informed decision when pricing your home for sale in Carlisle, here are the latest stats and sold comparables for the week of October 5 through 11, 2026…

Summary

• Total Home Sales: 2 homes sold (Down 12 from last week; Even from last year)
• Median Sale Price: $531,500 (Up $226,497 from $305,003 last week; Up $171,500 from $360,000 last year)
• Average Sale Price: $531,500 (Up $182,695 from $348,805 last week; Up $171,500 from $360,000 last year)
• Highest Sale Price: $693,000 (Down $13,010 from $706,010 last week; Up $323,000 from $370,000 last year)
• Lowest Sale Price: $370,000 (Up $250,000 from $120,000 last week; Up $20,000 from $350,000 last year)
• Average Days on Market: 12.5 (Down 16.5 from 29 last week; Up 11 from 1.5 last year)
• Absorption Rate (does not include Coming Soons in the Homes For Sale stats used to calculate this): 22.22%

The Comparables

Here is a list of the homes that sold last week of October 5 through 11, 2026 in 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) from highest price to lowest price:

• 2221 Longs Gap Rd: $693,000
• 140 Glendale St: $370,000

View and download full details for all 2 properties here

Interesting Facts

Go beyond the standard sales numbers. Below the surface of the real estate market data from October 5 through 11, 2026, are unique and fascinating details that make these sales stand out:

NASA Insulation and an Electrified Treehouse

The mountaintop retreat at 2221 Longs Gap Road features NASA space-age radiant heat shield barrier insulation in the attic structure, paired with a custom outdoor deer stand/treehouse fully wired with electric service for observation and hunting on its 5.02 private wooded acres.

The In-Garage Workshop Bathroom

Along with an in-ground pool and wraparound Trex decking, 2221 Longs Gap Road included a dedicated half bathroom built directly inside the oversized two-car workshop garage, a rare setup that keeps outdoor pool guests and workshop mechanics from tracking dirt inside the main home.

Realtor-Owned Campus Renovation

The home at 140 Glendale Street was owned, redesigned, and sold directly by a licensed Pennsylvania real estate salesperson acting as the sole member of an LLC, delivering a turnkey transformation within walking distance of Dickinson College and Penn State Dickinson Law.

The Price Per Square Foot Inversion

While 2221 Longs Gap Road sold for nearly double the gross price at $693,000, 140 Glendale Street commanded a far higher price per above-grade square foot at $264.66 compared to Longs Gap Road at $212.25. High-end designer finishes and walkability to downtown Carlisle generated a notable 24.7% premium per square foot over sprawling mountain acreage.

Dual Stacked Wood Hearths vs. Mountain Wet Bar

140 Glendale Street features two distinct wood-burning fireplaces stacked vertically on the main floor and in the fully finished lower level. In contrast, 2221 Longs Gap Road paired its massive brick living room fireplace with a built-in entertainer’s wet bar.

Synchronized Settlements

Despite representing opposite ends of the geographic spectrum (one nestled against Blue Mountain in North Middleton Township and the other inside Carlisle Borough), both homes settled on the exact same afternoon: Thursday, October 8, 2026.

Takeaways

Carlisle experienced a dramatic volume contraction following the late-September closing rush, pulling back from 14 transactions to just 2 sales. Despite the lighter transactional volume, the pricing floor stayed exceptionally strong with nothing closing under $370,000, propelling both the weekly median and average sale prices to $531,500. Buyer demand remained decisive for well-prepared listings, reflected in a brisk 12.5 average days on market. With 9 active homes currently competing on the market, the weekly absorption rate settled at 22.22%, signaling a steady, healthy environment where accurately priced properties continue to capture qualified buyers rapidly.

Real Estate stats are obtained from sources deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Stats are for 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) per Bright MLS.

Need help selling your home? Contact me anytime 🙂

Call / Text: CLICK HERE

Email: CLICK HERE