Weekly Carlisle Real Estate Sold Comparables Report | September 28 through October 4, 2026

So that you can make an up-to-date and informed decision when pricing your home for sale in Carlisle, here are the latest stats and sold comparables for the week of September 28 through October 4, 2026…

Summary

• Total Home Sales: 14 homes sold (Up 8 from last week; Up 3 from last year)
• Median Sale Price: $305,003 (Up $35,003 from $270,000 last week; Up $39,003 from $266,000 last year)
• Average Sale Price: $348,805 (Up $71,305 from $277,500 last week; Up $16,897 from $331,908 last year)
• Highest Sale Price: $706,010 (Up $179,010 from $527,000 last week; Down $59,079 from $765,089 last year)
• Lowest Sale Price: $120,000 (Up $24,000 from $96,000 last week; Up $89,000 from $31,000 last year)
• Average Days on Market: 29 (Up 11 from 18 last week; Up 13 from 16 last year)
• Absorption Rate (does not include Coming Soons in the Homes For Sale stats used to calculate this): 127.27% (1.27 homes sold per active home for sale; 0.79 weeks / 5.5 days of inventory based on 14 closed sales and 11 active listings)

The Comparables

Here is a list of the homes that sold last week of September 28 through October 4, 2026 in 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) from highest price to lowest price:

• 131 Blue Mountain Blvd: $706,010
• 1120 Sherwood Dr: $528,000
• 21 Prickly Pear Dr: $525,000
• 1306 Bosler Pl: $465,000
• 208 E Hillcrest Dr: $380,000
• 341 D Street: $351,250
• 505 S College St: $312,505
• 1202 White Birch Ln: $297,500
• 31 Parkview Dr: $285,000
• 534 N Hanover St: $275,000
• 2160 Waggoners Gap Rd: $250,000
• 4 Brook Side Dr: $223,000
• 785 Longs Gap Rd: $165,000
• 340 Cornman Rd: $120,000

View and download full details for all 14 properties here

Interesting Facts

Go beyond the standard sales numbers. Below the surface of the real estate market data from September 28 through October 4, 2026, are unique and fascinating details that make these sales stand out:

The Double-Entry Listing Glitch

In Bright MLS, 1202 White Birch Lane was recorded twice under two separate MLS numbers (PACB2057186 and PACB2057766). Both closed out on September 29, 2026, for the exact same sale price of $297,500. A superficial database export shows 15 transactions, but filtering out the duplicate reveals 14 unique physical homes changed hands.

Widespread Above-Asking Bidding

Over a third of all sales (5 of 14 homes) closed higher than their original list price. The biggest premium in dollar terms occurred at 1306 Bosler Place, which went $15,100 above asking ($465,000 versus $449,900). On a percentage basis, 340 Cornman Road took top honors, jumping 9.2% ($10,100 over asking) in only 3 days. Other over-ask closings included 505 S College Street (+$12,505 with a peculiar $5 final digit), 534 N Hanover Street (+$10,000), and 208 E Hillcrest Drive (+$5,100).

A Split-Speed Market

Half of the week’s properties (7 of 14) went under contract in 5 days or fewer. The 29-day overall average was heavily distorted by just two long-running listings: new construction at 341 D Street (195 DOM) and 31 Parkview Drive (94 DOM). Removing those two legacy properties drops the average market time for the remaining 12 homes down to a blistering 9.5 days.

Top Dollar with Zero Days on Market

The week’s highest transaction was 131 Blue Mountain Boulevard, which closed at $706,010.34. Entered into the MLS strictly for comparable reporting purposes, it logged 0 days on market. The contract for the new-build “Charlotte” model was actually signed back in February 2026 before completing construction and settling in late September.

Buying Land Disguised as a Home

While 340 Cornman Road registered as the lowest sale price of the week at $120,000 for a 1983 manufactured home, the true purchase was the land and infrastructure. The 1.09-acre parcel in the Mountain View Baptist Church Plan came ready-built with an existing two-car detached garage, drilled well, and mound septic system, providing a ready-to-build homesite at entry-level pricing.

Rare Utilities and Mechanicals

2160 Waggoners Gap Road ($250,000) stands out for utilizing a dedicated sewage holding tank system rather than a standard septic absorption field or municipal sewer. On the higher-end side, 1120 Sherwood Drive ($528,000) featured a whole-home Generac propane generator, an intercom system, and direct basement access through the garage.

Takeaways

The Carlisle area real estate market demonstrated exceptional momentum during the week of September 28 through October 4, 2026, recording 14 closed transactions and pushing both median and average sale prices significantly above prior week and prior year benchmarks. With active inventory tightly compressed at just 11 available homes (excluding incoming listings), the weekly absorption rate reached an aggressive 127.27%, representing barely half a week of available supply. Buyer competition remained sharp across multiple price tiers, with over a third of properties closing above original asking prices and half the market going under contract in 5 days or fewer.

Real Estate stats are obtained from sources deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Stats are for 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) per Bright MLS.

Need help selling your home? Contact me anytime 🙂

Call / Text: CLICK HERE

Email: CLICK HERE