Weekly Carlisle Real Estate Sold Comparables Report | May 18 through 24, 2026
So that you can make an up-to-date and informed decision when pricing your home for sale in Carlisle, here are the latest stats and sold comparables for the week of May 18 through 24, 2026…
Summary
17013
- Total Home Sales: 5 homes sold (up 1 from last week; up 0 from last year)
- Median Sale Price: $207,000 (down $2,250 from $209,250 last week; down $128,000 from $335,000 last year)
- Average Sale Price: $247,840 (up $23,965 from $223,875 last week; down $47,740 from $295,580 last year)
- Highest Sale Price: $514,800 (up $152,800 from $362,000 last week; up $29,800 from $485,000 last year)
- Lowest Sale Price: $87,500 (down $27,500 from $115,000 last week; up $44,600 from $42,900 last year)
- Average Days of Market: 11 (up 3 from 8 last week; up 2 from 9 last year)
17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District)
No closings week of May 18 through 24, 2026. No closings previous week. No closings previous year same week.
The Comparables
Here is a list of the homes that sold last week May 18 through 24, 2026 in 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) from highest price to lowest price:
17013
- 114 Blue Mountain Blvd: $514,800
- 239 G St: $250,000
- 140 Glendale St: $207,000
- 151 N Bedford St: $179,900
- 425 N West St: $87,500
View and download full details for all 5 properties here
17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District)
No closings week of May 18 through 24, 2026. No closings previous week. No closings previous year same week.
Interesting Facts
While standard market reports focus entirely on average sale prices and typical days on market, a deeper dive into the specific details of this week’s closings reveals unique structural anomalies, historical upgrades, and layout surprises that standard statistics completely overlook.
Age Is Just a Number (When Renovated)
Surprisingly, Carlisle’s newest build wasn’t the fastest to fly off the shelf. The oldest home sold this week, a brick rowhome at 151 N Bedford St built in 1880, went under contract in just one day on the market. Because it was completely updated in 2020, buyers didn’t hesitate, and the home closed right at its $179,900 asking price. Conversely, the brand-new 2024 construction at 114 Blue Mountain Blvd took 11 days to sell and required $5,000 in seller concessions to secure its $514,800 list price.
The Century-Old “Zero-Bedroom” Anomaly
The most unusual sale of the week belongs to 425 N West St, a detached home built in 1900 that is officially recorded as having zero bedrooms and one bathroom. Labeled as needing “Major Rehab,” this property was the only one in the entire batch to sell below its asking price, closing at 92.2% of the list price after a lengthy 35 days on the market. Interestingly, the seller even offered financing to well-qualified individuals to help get the deal done, highlighting the creative tactics sometimes needed to move distressed properties.
The “As-Is” Property Spurred a Bidding War
You might expect a home explicitly marketed “as-is” and needing updates to command lower offers, but 140 Glendale St proved otherwise. Despite being a 1950 build previously used as a rental, it sold for $207,000 (103.5% of its $200,000 list price). It seems the appeal of a generously sized yard, a large shed, and proximity to Dickinson College completely outweighed the required elbow grease, driving buyers to secure the home in just three days.
The “Missing Middle” Commanded the Highest Premiums
While the cheapest and most expensive homes sold at or below their asking prices, the mid-tier properties generated the most urgency. The two properties built between 1950 and 2001 (Glendale St and G St) were the only ones to sell above their list prices. The 2001 townhouse at 239 G St was the top performer in this regard, closing at $250,000 (more than $10,000 (104.21%) over its original list price) after just five days on the market. This suggests intense buyer competition right in the $200,000 to $250,000 sweet spot.
Takeaways
The $200,000 to $250,000 range is doing well and moving fast. Well-priced listings are generating bidding wars and closing above asking price in under a week. Completely updated older homes are moving almost instantly, while high-end new builds and distressed properties are taking a little longer to sell, and often require concessions or creative financing. Focusing on strategic updates and precise pricing is the most effective strategy for sellers to capture peak demand and secure the best possible price and terms.
Real Estate stats are obtained from sources deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Stats are for 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) per Bright MLS.
