Monthly Carlisle Real Estate Sold Comparables Report | April 2026

So that you can make an informed decision when pricing your home for sale in Carlisle, here are the latest stats and sold comparables for the month of April 2026.

• Total Home Sales: 43 homes sold (79.17% Up 19 from last year)
• Median Sale Price: $304,000 (3.93% Up $11,500 from $292,500 last year)
• Average Sale Price: $347,591 (4.08% Down $14,786 from $362,377 last year)
• Highest Sale Price: $875,000 (12.5% Down $125,000 from $1,000,000 last year)
• Lowest Sale Price: $3,000 (98.46% Down $192,000 from $195,000 last year)
• Average Days on Market: 30 (37.5% Down 18 from 48 last year)

Interesting Facts

• Significant Volume Jump: The Carlisle market saw a massive increase in activity this spring, with 43 homes sold in April 2026 compared to just 24 closed sales in April 2025.
• Steady Price Appreciation: The median closed price climbed to $304,000 in April 2026. This is an increase from the $292,300 median closed price recorded exactly one year prior.
• Fast-Moving Inventory: Half of all homes sold in April 2026 spent 8 days or fewer on the market.
• Historical Charm: Buyers are purchasing properties with significant history. The median age of a sold property in April 2026 was 62 years old. The oldest home sold was 161 years old, dating its original construction back to approximately 1865.
• Competitive Offers: Sellers are largely getting what they ask for, with the median closed price being exactly 100% of the list price. Several properties commanded premiums well over asking, such as a home on Waggoners Gap Road that closed at 113.75% of its list price and a property on W Pomfret St that closed at 112.84%.
• Broad Price Spectrum: The April 2026 market accommodated a wide variety of buyers and budgets, with closed prices ranging from a minimum of $3,000 to a maximum of $875,000.

Takeaways for Carlisle Home Sellers

Strategic Pricing Remains Critical

With the median closed price hitting $304,000 and a median list-to-close ratio of exactly 100%, the data shows that properly priced homes are immediately capturing buyer attention. Overpricing can lead to stagnation, while precise pricing strategies are resulting in competitive offers right out of the gate.

Expect a Brisk Pace

The market is moving swiftly. The median days on market for April 2026 was a rapid 8 days. Sellers need to have their next steps planned before listing, as an acceptable offer could materialize within the first week of showings. However, the average days on market was 30 days, meaning unique or higher-tier properties might require a few extra weeks to secure the right buyer.

Prepare for Increased Competition

With 43 properties closing this April versus only 24 last April, there is more inventory successfully moving through the local market. To stand out among the increased volume, sellers must prioritize professional presentation, high-quality digital marketing, and impactful staging to ensure their listing captures maximum online and in-person engagement.

All the Comparables

Sold comparables are from April 1 – 30, 2026 in 17013 and 17015 (but only 17015 areas that are located in Carlisle School District)

View and Download Summary of April 2026 Sold Comparables Details

View and Download April 2026 Sold Comparables Full Details

Here is a list of the homes that sold last month [April 1, 2026 – April 30, 2026] from highest price to lowest price:

17013 Zip Code:

• 275 N Middleton Rd: $799,900
• 307 S Orange St: $710,000
• 141 W Louther Street: $545,000
• 160 Wertz Run Rd: $540,000
• 26 American Ave: $537,500
• 136 W Pomfret St: $536,000
• 104 White Deer Way: $525,000
• 14 Garden Drive: $480,000
• 705 Sutton Dr: $442,000
• 1200 Sadler Dr: $410,000
• 226 Walnut St: $360,000
• 813 Nesbit Dr: $342,500
• 7 Sussex Dr: $336,000
• 841 N Pitt St: $330,000
• 927 Hamilton Street: $330,000
• 1908 George Ave: $312,000
• Unlisted Address: $304,000
• 278 Longs Gap Rd: $279,900
• 312 Sherman Ave: $275,000
• 2281 Waggoners Gap Road: $273,000
• 1510 Hemlock Avenue: $269,900
• 413 Eisenhower Drive: $257,000
• 508 S Pitt Street: $240,000
• 257 Arch St: $233,650
• 125 E North St: $215,500
• 232 Henderson St: $195,000
• 830 N Middleton Road: $124,900
• 412 N West St: $111,000
• 10 Northview Dr: $109,950

17015 Zip Code:

(but only 17015 areas that are located in Carlisle School District)

• 1 Peyton Dr: $875,000
• 4 Peyton Dr: $780,000
• 19 Sandy Bottom Rd: $640,000
• 40 Moongale Dr: $329,900
• 937 Factory Street: $197,500
• 36 Kerrs Ave: $160,150
• 115 Tower Circle: $5,000
• 141 Tower Circle: $3,000

Real Estate stats are obtained from sources deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Stats [April 1 – 30, 2026] per Bright MLS.