Weekly Carlisle Real Estate Sold Comparables Report | May 25 through 31, 2026

So that you can make an up-to-date and informed decision when pricing your home for sale in Carlisle, here are the latest stats and sold comparables for the week of May 25 through 31, 2026…

Summary

17013

• Total Home Sales: 10 homes sold (Down 2 from last week; Up 1 from last year)
• Median Sale Price: $265,000 (Up $15,000 from $250,000 last week; Up $11,000 from $254,000 last year)
• Average Sale Price: $380,542 (Up $10,542 from $370,000 last week; Up $25,542 from $355,000 last year)
• Highest Sale Price: $1,000,000 (Up $241,000 from $759,000 last week; Up $100,000 from $900,000 last year)
• Lowest Sale Price: $125,000 (Down $54,900 from $179,900 last week; Up $25,000 from $100,000 last year)
• Average Days of Market: 32 (Up 2 days from 30 days last week; Down 3 days from 35 days last year)

17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District)

• Total Home Sales: 6 homes sold (Down 1 from last week; Down 2 from last year)
• Median Sale Price: $282,500 (Down $5,000 from $287,500 last week; Up $22,500 from $260,000 last year)
• Average Sale Price: $299,291 (Down $10,000 from $309,291 last week; Up $15,000 from $284,291 last year)
• Highest Sale Price: $623,745 (Up $23,755 from $599,990 last week; Up $123,745 from $500,000 last year)
• Lowest Sale Price: $35,000 (Up $13,000 from $22,000 last week; Down $15,000 from $50,000 last year)
• Average Days of Market: 35 (Down 1 day from 36 days last week; Up 2 days from 33 days last year)

The Comparables

Here is a list of the homes that sold last week May 25 through 31, 2026 in 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) from highest price to lowest price:

17013

• 159 N Hanover St: $1,000,000
• 26 Suebecca Dr: $759,000
• 922 Hamilton St: $380,000
• 206 Cumberland Dr: $345,000
• 609 N East St: $280,000
• 464 Wolfs Bridge Rd: $250,000
• 2691 Spring Rd: $245,000
• 129 Darr Ave: $228,420
• 19 N East St: $193,000
• 102 Oriole Dr: $125,000

View and download full details for all 10 properties here

17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District)

• 17 Aquila Cir: $623,745
• 37 W Eppley Dr: $520,000
• 372 Burnt House Rd: $385,000
• 50 Eastwick Ln: $180,000
• 80 Vasilios Dr: $52,000
• 7 Buttonwood Ln: $35,000

View and download full details for all 6 properties here

Interesting Facts

Go beyond the standard sales numbers. Below the surface of the real estate market data from May 25 through May 31, 2026, are unique features, historic roots, and fascinating details that make these properties stand out.

Century-Defying Character

• The Longest-Standing Structure: Built in 1880, the charming stone row home at 19 N East Street is an incredible 146 years old. It successfully blended historic integrity with modern convenience by closing last week with a fully remodeled kitchen and a private upper-level balcony.
• Vintage Built-Ins: The traditional-style home at 609 N East Street (built in 1929) preserved its classic 20th-century roots with original wood trim, a beautifully crafted built-in bookcase, and a full walk-up attic.

Harnessing the Sun

• Green Energy Upgrades: Alternative energy was a quiet trend among last week’s closings. The property at 206 Cumberland Drive features integrated solar panels to provide predictable utility bills.
• Detached Solar Infrastructure: Taking green energy a step further, the 3.32-acre estate at 372 Burnt House Road features a rare, completely standalone detached solar panel system to power the property independently.

Architectural Quirks & Layout Flips

• Hidden Attic Access: At 609 N East Street, you won’t find the attic stairs in a common hallway. The walk-up steps to the massive third-floor storage and expansion space are located directly inside the second bedroom.
• Second-Floor Laundry Convenience: While older Cape Cod styles usually relegate chores to the basement, 2691 Spring Road features a highly functional layout flip with the main laundry area situated on the second floor right next to the primary walk-in closet.
• Oil-to-Gas Conversion: The split-level home at 922 Hamilton Street underwent a massive mechanical overhaul in 2023, completely eliminating its reliance on heating oil by converting the hot water, central heating, and kitchen cooking systems entirely to natural gas.

Wood-Burning Nostalgia

• The Ultimate Cozy Factor: Despite robust modern heating systems, local buyers still prize traditional warmth. Three distinct properties closed last week featuring classic wood-burning stoves or fireplace inserts to supplement their regular heating: 129 Darr Avenue, 206 Cumberland Drive, and 922 Hamilton Street.

Above-Asking Bidding Battles

• Rapid-Fire Decisions: Extreme buyer demand caused multiple homes to blast right past their original list prices in mere days. Sellers at 19 N East Street, 129 Darr Avenue, 206 Cumberland Drive, and 2691 Spring Road all accepted winning offers above asking price after spending an average of just 4 to 8 days on the market.

Major Milestones

The True Cost of Convenience: The manufactured home at 102 Oriole Drive represented the lowest purchase price of the week at $125,000. However, it comes with a robust $842 monthly association fee because the community handles absolutely every aspect of exterior maintenance, including all lawn care, snow removal, trash collection, public water, and community septic work.

The Million-Dollar Commercial Footprint: The absolute highest transaction of the week belonged to 159 N Hanover Street, which changed hands for a milestone $1,000,000. This massive three-story mixed-use downtown building closed at 100% occupancy and features a premium 20-space private parking lot right in the center of the borough.

Takeaways

The final week of May highlights a highly competitive and resilient Carlisle real estate market. Year-over-year median prices continue to climb across both the 17013 and 17015 zip codes, underscoring strong, sustained property values. The lightning-fast pace of recent bidding battles, paired with milestone transactions like the million-dollar downtown closing, proves that motivated buyers are actively looking and willing to move quickly for the right property. For prospective sellers, precise competitive pricing and showcasing unique property assets remain the most effective strategies to command premium offers in today’s market.

Real Estate stats are obtained from sources deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Stats are for 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) per Bright MLS.