Weekly Carlisle Real Estate Sold Comparables Report | May 11 through 17, 2026

So that you can make an up-to-date and informed decision when pricing your home for sale in Carlisle, here are the latest stats and sold comparables for the week of May 11 through 17, 2026…

Summary

17013

• Total Home Sales: 4 homes sold (UP 3 from 1 last week; DOWN 4 from 8 last year)
• Median Sale Price: $209,250 (DOWN $5,750 from $215,000 last week; DOWN $35,350 from $244,600 last year)
• Average Sale Price: $223,875 (UP $8,875 from $215,000 last week; DOWN $101,013 from $324,888 last year)
• Highest Sale Price: $362,000 (UP $147,000 from $215,000 last week; DOWN $423,000 from $785,000 last year)
• Lowest Sale Price: $115,000 (DOWN $100,000 from $215,000 last week; DOWN $65,000 from $180,000 last year)
• Average Days of Market: 8 (DOWN 110 from 118 last week; DOWN 2 from 10 last year)

17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District)

None

The Comparables

Here is a list of the homes that sold last week May 11 through 17, 2026 in 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) from highest price to lowest price:

17013

• 26 Longstreet Drive: $362,000 (3 beds, 1,800 sq ft)
• 1883 George Avenue: $218,500 (2 beds, 891 sq ft)
• 9 Partridge Circle: $200,000 (2 beds, 1,280 sq ft)
• 121 Oriole Drive: $115,000 (2 beds, 1,228 sq ft)

View and download full details for all 4 properties here

17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District)

None

Interesting Facts

Here are some unique and less obvious insights drawn from the real estate data across the three weeks provided.

Unique Property Features and Zoning

• The highest-priced property wasn’t just a house, it was a farm: The most expensive property across all three timeframes was a $785,000, 17.19-acre equestrian estate at 1402 Longs Gap Rd, which included a 9-stall horse barn, paddocks, and a riding ring.
• Dual-purpose living: A home that sold in May 2025 at 1010 Harrisburg Pike was uniquely zoned for both residential and commercial use, marketed as a perfect setup to run a business from home.
• Land leases affect the bottom line: The lowest-priced property from May 2026 (121 Oriole Drive for $115,000) is a double-wide modular home situated in a mobile home park. Because the land is not owned, the property carries a monthly land lease and HOA fee totaling $772 with a 100-year remaining lease.

Age Extremes vs. Time on Market

• Historic homes took longer to sell: The oldest property sold across all tracked weeks was a historic brick end-of-row townhouse built in 1880 at 110 S Bedford St. Notably, this was also the most difficult property to sell, sitting on the market for 118 days.
• Blink and you miss it: Excluding that historic home, properties moved incredibly fast. The median Days on Market (DOM) for the week of May 11-17 in 2025 was just 7 days, and in the same week in 2026, it was even faster at just 5 days.

Price Per Square Foot Anomalies

• Small footprint, big premium: While the luxury equestrian estate predictably had the highest price per square foot at $293.46, the second-highest wasn’t a luxury mansion. It was a modest, 891-square-foot ranch home at 1883 George Ave that commanded a surprising $245.23 per square foot..
• The lowest cost per square foot: The modular home at 121 Oriole Drive offered the most space for the lowest initial cost, coming in at just $93.65 per square foot.

Bidding War Trends

• Over-asking was the norm in 2025: During the week of May 11-17, 2025, buyers were highly aggressive. Half of all homes sold (4 out of 8) went for over their original asking price, with one property reaching 104.35% of the list price.
• 2026 still saw premiums: By the same week in 2026, the market was still competitive but slightly cooler. Two out of the four homes sold went for exactly asking price, while the other two sold above asking, peaking at 101.63% of the list price.

Takeaways

Ultimately, the Carlisle real estate market remains both dynamic and highly nuanced. While overall sales volume and average prices have cooled compared to the heightened activity of May 2025, the market continues to move at a rapid pace, with the median property selling in just five days. Buyers are still competitive, often willing to pay the asking price or higher for the right home. Furthermore, the sheer diversity of recent sales (ranging from an affordable land-lease modular home to a sprawling 17-acre equestrian estate) demonstrates that top-level statistics don’t always tell the whole story. Understanding these underlying trends, unique property features, and price-per-square-foot anomalies is essential in helping you strategically price and market your home for a successful sale.

Real Estate stats are obtained from sources deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Stats are for 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) per Bright MLS.