Weekly Carlisle Real Estate Sold Comparables Report | August 31 through September 6, 2026

So that you can make an up-to-date and informed decision when pricing your home for sale in Carlisle, here are the latest stats and sold comparables for the week of August 31 through September 6, 2026…

Summary

• Total Home Sales: 6 homes sold (Down 1 from last week; Down 1 from last year)
• Median Sale Price: $289,750 (Down $250 from $290,000 last week; Down $5,250 from $295,000 last year)
• Average Sale Price: $339,917 (Down $23,175 from $363,092 last week; Up $61,660 from $278,257 last year)
• Highest Sale Price: $650,000 (Up $88,355 from $561,645 last week; Up $250,100 from $399,900 last year)Lowest Sale Price: $210,000 (Down $25,000 from $235,000 last week; Up $165,100 from $44,900 last year)
• Average Days on Market: 15 (Up 4 from 11 last week; Down 74 from 89 last year)
• Absorption Rate (does not include Coming Soons in the Homes For Sale stats used to calculate this): 100% (6 homes sold / 6 active homes for sale, representing 1.0 week of inventory)

The Comparables

Here is a list of the homes that sold last week of August 31 through September 6, 2026 in 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) from highest price to lowest price:

• 1009 Drayer Ct: $650,000
• 1500 Newville Rd: $320,000
• 6 Strawberry Ln: $292,500
• 1924 Esther Dr: $287,000
• 337 Franklin St: $280,000
• 120 E North St: $210,000

View and download full details for all 6 properties here

Interesting Facts

Go beyond the standard sales numbers. Below the surface of the real estate market data from August 31 through September 6, 2026, are unique and fascinating details that make these sales stand out:

The In-Town Acreage Anomaly

1009 Drayer Ct closed on an expansive 1.66-acre lot situated directly inside Carlisle Borough limits. In a borough setting where typical parcels average 0.06 to 0.25 acres, this property spans nearly 28 times the lot size of 120 E North St (0.06 acres), delivering country-level privacy within walking distance of town.

A Private In-Home Sauna

Tucked into the partially finished basement of 1009 Drayer Ct is a built-in wood sauna, an uncommon luxury amenity in Carlisle residential resale data.

The 50/50 Municipal Balance

Sales split perfectly down municipal lines, with exactly 3 homes closing in Carlisle Borough (1009 Drayer Ct, 337 Franklin St, and 120 E North St) and 3 closing in North Middleton Township (6 Strawberry Ln, 1924 Esther Dr, and 1500 Newville Road).

Fifty Percent Sold Above Asking

Half of last week’s transactions closed over the original list price. 6 Strawberry Ln fetched $17,500 over asking after triggering a competitive multi-offer deadline in 6 days. Just around the corner, 1924 Esther Dr secured $12,100 over list price in just 4 days. Even 120 E North St in the historic district went for $10,000 over asking.

More Half Baths Than Full Baths

In 1,288 square feet, 1924 Esther Dr features an unusual layout containing twice as many half bathrooms as full bathrooms, offering 1 full bath alongside 2 separate powder rooms located on the main and lower levels.

“Optical Illusion” Ceilings

The public marketing for 1500 Newville Road uniquely called out its renovated vaulted ceilings as an “Optical Illusion” that buyers had to see to believe, alongside a 90% interior transformation.

Maximizing Historic Footprints

Both century-old homes showcased creative spatial design. 337 Franklin St (built in 1924) features a finished walk-up attic with open A-frame rafters and integrated perimeter bookcases, while 120 E North St (built in 1890) maximized an ultra-narrow 2,614-square-foot downtown lot with a composite deck, stone porch, pergola, and outdoor grilling patio.

Takeaways

The Carlisle area real estate market demonstrated remarkable balance and velocity during the first week of September 2026. A 100% absorption rate and a stable median price point of $289,750 reflect strong underlying buyer demand, especially for move-in ready homes under $300,000 where half the inventory sold over list price in under a week. While the borough’s standout $650,000 estate sale pushed the average transaction value higher, the core volume continues to move at a brisk 15-day market pace, proving that well-prepared properties across both Carlisle Borough and North Middleton Township remain in high demand.

Real Estate stats are obtained from sources deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Stats are for 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) per Bright MLS.

Need help selling your home? Contact me anytime 🙂

Call / Text: CLICK HERE

Email: CLICK HERE