Weekly Carlisle Real Estate Sold Comparables Report | August 31 through September 6, 2026
So that you can make an up-to-date and informed decision when pricing your home for sale in Carlisle, here are the latest stats and sold comparables for the week of September 7 through 13, 2026…
Summary
- Total Home Sales: 5 homes sold (up 1 from last week; Down 2 from last year)
- Median Sale Price: $218,000 (Down $71,750 from $289,750 last week; Down $82,000 from $300,000 last year)
- Average Sale Price: $499,593 (Up $122,218 from $377,375 last week; Up $100,593 from $399,000 last year)
- Highest Sale Price: $894,000 (Up $244,000 from $650,000 last week; Up $54,000 from $840,000 last year)
- Lowest Sale Price: $27,000 (Down $183,000 from $210,000 last week; Down $158,000 from $185,000 last year)
- Average Days on Market: 20 (Up 8 from 12 last week; Down 27 from 47 last year)
- Absorption Rate (does not include Coming Soons in the Homes For Sale stats used to calculate this): 83.3%
The Comparables
Here is a list of the homes that sold last week of September 7 through 13, 2026 in 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) from highest price to lowest price:
- 3 Katie Ln: $894,000
- 1911 Longs Gap Road: $640,000
- 42 Bennington Way: $523,464
- 21 H St: $218,000
- 202 Marion Avenue: $217,500
View and download full details for all 5 properties here
Interesting Facts
Go beyond the standard sales numbers. Below the surface of the real estate market data from September 7 through 13, 2026, are unique and fascinating details that make these sales stand out:
Century Spanning Inventory
The architectural spread this past week spanned more than two centuries of local craftsmanship, led by 3 Katie Lane, a preserved 1798 Federal brick home on 7.73 acres along the Yellow Breeches Creek, down to modern new construction with the 2026 completion of The Henley model at 42 Bennington Way.
Extreme Valuation Bifurcation
Pricing saw a massive $867,000 spread between the week’s top residential property and entry level inventory, which featured land lease and off grid recreational opportunities such as an unheated 1900 cottage on Bellaire Park Road with 250 feet of Conodoguinet Creek frontage and a 1995 manufactured home on Northview Drive.
Water and Outdoor Amenities
Two closed transactions featured rare direct water access, one offering private fishing rights on the Yellow Breeches and another fronting the Conodoguinet Creek, alongside equestrian facilities including a 10 stall bank barn, riding ring, and four fenced paddocks.
Speed of Urban Borough Sales
Carlisle Borough properties moved with rapid turnaround times, as demonstrated by 21 H Street, which secured a buyer in just 6 days on market.
Takeaways
The Carlisle market showcased significant diversity this past week, marked by a jump in average sale prices driven by luxury rural and equestrian properties even as median pricing moderated toward entry tier borough homes. Buyer demand remained decisive across well positioned single family and suburban homes, resulting in brisk absorption alongside steady turnover across both historic estates and modern developments.
Real Estate stats are obtained from sources deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Stats are for 17013 and 17015 (but only the portion that is within Carlisle School District) per Bright MLS.
Need help selling your home? Contact me anytime 🙂
Call / Text: CLICK HERE
Email: CLICK HERE
